I just don't see Garoppolo as worth a first-round pick.

 

 

Who said to draft Garoppolo in the 1st? I said 2nd round. 

---

By watching him CRUM, CRUM, CRUMMMMM-BLE in the face of pressure the only time he faced a legit team vs USC.... Thats what he'll face routinely in the big boy league. 

 

Just like his brother. Same traits/ Bloodlines. 

 

He will be a garbage pro. 

Wait, so you're saying that because David Carr was little more than a serviceable backup, Derek Carr's instantly going to be garbage?

 

The Mountain West Conference isn't the SEC, but compared to FCS, it might as well be. Garoppolo faced sub-subpar pass rushers and corners, and he lit it up. Carr faced some NFL talent on defenses, and he lit it up as well. Never said that Carr wouldn't have to sit, but I contend that he will be a more successful pro than Garoppolo.

---

...So then, you ADMIT I had a valid point with that, thus not "agenda driven" or "attention seeking".

Uhhhh...I don't know if you've been paying attention but I have never been a fan of Marcedes.


That doesn't dispute the fact that you have been on here whoring for attention for years.

---

Wait, so you're saying that because David Carr was little more than a serviceable backup, Derek Carr's instantly going to be garbage?

 

The Mountain West Conference isn't the SEC, but compared to FCS, it might as well be. Garoppolo faced sub-subpar pass rushers and corners, and he lit it up. Carr faced some NFL talent on defenses, and he lit it up as well. Never said that Carr wouldn't have to sit, but I contend that he will be a more successful pro than Garoppolo.

 

I can't wait until Carr repeats USC performance on a weekly basis. I just hope its not for us...

 

Hopefully Caldwell chooses a QB elsewhere. Otherwise, a new GM will be picking our next QB. 

---

By watching him CRUM, CRUM, CRUMMMMM-BLE in the face of pressure the only time he faced a legit team vs USC.... Thats what he'll face routinely in the big boy league.


Just like his brother. Same traits/ Bloodlines.


He will be a garbage pro.

Garoppolo also had trouble facing pressure on the FCS level. Using your logic he'll also be garbage

---

Meh 

 

I only take Mack on a trade back, not a Carr but would like to see what other QBs were still available in that mock, not a big A.Robinson fan tho in the 3rd would be ok

---

<B><FONT color=cyan>Jags this is your year</FONT></B>

Garrapolo = Romo because they both come from a small school


And


Carr = well David Carr because they are brothers

---

Overdrafting? Wanna have a little friendly side bet that Niklas doesn't last past pick 50?

 

I'll bet you he's not the best available player when we select.

 

Since, you know... that's what I said.

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

By watching him CRUM, CRUM, CRUMMMMM-BLE in the face of pressure the only time he faced a legit team vs USC.... Thats what he'll face routinely in the big boy league. 

 

Just like his brother. Same traits/ Bloodlines. 

 

He will be a garbage pro. 

 

Is this based on your own experiences?  I can't help but feel it is.  Just like your high school coach that you saw in Del Rio (the one that couldn't develop players.)

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

Garrapolo = Romo because they both come from a small school


And


Carr = well David Carr because they are brothers

 

Just like the Palmers and Newtons.  Clones.

 

And speaking of bloodlines, I'd take a late flyer on Jake Murphy (Dale's son.)

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

I'll bet you he's not the best available player when we select.

 

Since, you know... that's what I said.

 

Oh, so you want to keep it totally subjective...

 

Figures. 

 

At least what I suggested has a definitive right/ wrong outcome. 

---

Who said to draft Garoppolo in the 1st? I said 2nd round.

He has the same pocket issues Carr has.

---

He has the same pocket issues Carr has.

 

Garoppolo didn't look as skittish to me as Carr does when faced with pressure. 

---

Should never have let Jordan Rodgers go. Bloodlines man, bloodlines.

---

Oh, so you want to keep it totally subjective...

 

Figures. 

 

At least what I suggested has a definitive right/ wrong outcome. 

 

No, I'm keeping honest to what I said.  Something you simply can't do.  Your argument is not mine.

 

If we pass, I'm right.  We didn't feel he was the best player available.

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

I think we need a right guard and center before we need a right tackle.....

---

No, I'm keeping honest to what I said.  Something you simply can't do.  Your argument is not mine.

 

If we pass, I'm right.  We didn't feel he was the best player available.

 

Oh, we didn't feel that he was the best player available if we do pass.... yes I agree to that, thats kind of an obvious statement though. 

 

However, if we pass that doesn't necessarily mean we did the right thing, or that we didn't ultimately just let a better player slide further. 

 

David Caldwell and staff are far from infallible. 

 

Sometimes I think that some of you have this mindset that well whatever Caldwell decides to do is the right decision. 

---

I think we need a right guard and center before we need a right tackle.....

 

I'd agree with that. At some point if the value becomes too great, its better to just take the decidedly better player over the position. 

---

I would be more than happy with those picks. To think 8 more picks come afterward is exciting too! :thumbsup:

---

What lies behind us, and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us.







 

Love the Allen Robinson pick but I don't think he will last till the 3rd, don't like the Carr pick really I would rather have Mettenberger

---