(06-28-2018, 11:49 AM)Caldrac Wrote: Doubt it. Half the St. Louis team would have made it that year. Kurt Warner would have been probably the No. 1 overall player. Edgerrin James, Jevon Kearse & Warren Sapp would be pretty high on the list. How did you overlook Tony Brackens though? Fred Taylor wouldn't be in the top six. He wasn't even a top ten leader in rushing yards in 1999. He was still splitting carries with Stewart that year and he only started in nine games. Stewart damn near doubled Freddy in TD's that year with just seven starts to his name.

Boselli, Hardy, Lake, Brackens, Smith, Searcy & Brunell would have made it though. I don't know how high or low but they were all in the pro-bowl in 1999. You could then maybe make a case for McCardell. He was pretty decent in 1999. Smith would have been the most likely player to land inside the top six though. He was arguably the best receiver in 1999. Marvin Harrison was good too. But outside of him and Smith it was just okay. Randy Moss was up there along with Tim Brown and Cris Carter. Maybe Muhsin Muhammad too.