(08-10-2018, 05:34 AM)Jags02 Wrote:

(08-10-2018, 04:21 AM)JUNGLE CAT 2017 Wrote: I know what you mean. Scott Orndoff has the look of a much better player than his lowly roster position. O'Shaughnessy is a VERY active player. He really keeps busy out there.

I noticed Orndoff for the first time when he caught that TD, but I recall him from the draft as a player I was looking at. O'Shaughnessy gets the occasional pass catch, but I always find myself wanting more from him. I think Niles Paul will effectively supplant what he brings to the offense. That said, Goolsby just intrigues the heck out of me and I suspect he'll ultimately beat them both out, but that's a wait-and-see proposition.

Walker has bounced around too much. If he had it, it would have shown. Chris Reed. Plus, I didn't see Josh Wells on your list. He has stepped in for Parnell often enough, and he seems to be the first man up - filling in at LT, RT and LG. That's a real go-to guy.

Walker vs Reed is wide open for the last backup G spot. As for Josh Wells, I agree and have him behind Cam, but I mistakenly called him "Jonathan". It's edited now.

Shatley over Adams so far. Tyler is a terrific center and doubles as a guard. Adams is debatable. 

Agreed so far, but I'm interested to see more of Adams knowing Shatley is only so good.

I favor Ankou over Bennett. Michael is not holding up well as a pro. 

Another wide open competition. Michael made a nice play early in this game.

I dropped Fowler and kept Smoot and Dimick. L. Johnson to practice squad (unless I've missed something). 

I gotta keep Fowler over Dimick at this point. Dimick was only in there because Campbell, Smoot and Fowler were all not playing.

When in doubt, there's always the practice squad favoring more experience.

---

(08-10-2018, 04:48 AM)JUNGLE CAT 2017 Wrote: Moncrief is meh. He was brought in to compete at the highest possible level. Where is he? Certainly not a one or two guy at all. To me he's a dog in the manger - holding back several players, who aren't receiving the reps they need to shine.

Fowler simply isn't a Coughlin guy. There was the beating he gave the wife of his child by proxy. That's unacceptable. Then what do you know? He goes meat-head and sends a guy's groceries flying. Now look. Personal conduct spilled onto the playing field. One game was NOT enough. He was unfairly and inappropriately protected in that attack on his child's mother. I'll take Smoot over that puke any day of the week, especially since he doesn't seem to conduct himself in such a way to protect his availability for work on Sundays.


BTW, I tried to correct the original post before I received a reply. So the version in your initial reply doesn't reflect the few changes I made.

I'm sticking with Fowler unless we can trade him.

As for Moncrief, I'm intrigued by what he brings to the table with his height, speed, skill-set and veteran presence. He'll stay put this year unless he continues to flame out this Preseason.