The following players never missed an extra points for the Jags:

Seth Marler, Hayden Epstein, Tim Seder, Danny Boyd, Steve Lindsey, Richie Cunningham, Jarrett Holmes

 

Scobee's Extra Point misses:

1 against Tennessee (2006) - We still won

1 against Pittsburgh (2007) - We still won

2 against Tennessee (2009, 2013) - we lost both by more than 3 points

1 against Minnesota (2009) - We lost by a field goal

 

Mike Hollis's Extra Point Misses: 

2 against Cleveland (1995, 2006)- we still won both

1 against Chicago (2002) - we lost by more than 10 points

 

Carney's Extra Point Misses:

1 against Houston (2007) - we still won

 

We never lost a game by 1 point because of a missed Point After Touchdown specifically.  And the proposal isn't to get rid of the extra point, just to make it automatic.  It's not even really automatic, because here are 9 missed extra points by the Jags.

---