Quote:Sorry, but no it's not. Crabtree became the most overrated WR when the 49ers started winning, before that he was considered a possible bust. He's average at best and only a fool would take him over Shorts. Unlike Crabtree, Shorts made Sherman work for his money. 

 

 

EDIT: Also your credibility was shattered last off season when you tried to argue that Gabbert was better than Henne so please think before you talk from now on. 

 

Coming from the male version of Jaguar woman?  That is hilarious. 

 

I remember going to a practice last off season, coming to this board and specifically saying that Henne was better than Gabbert.  But yes, I did say Gabbert played well in the Jets preseason game, which he did. 

 

Oh yeah, Crabtree actually makes contested catches.  Shorts not so much.  And Shorts did nothing in that Seahawks game until the Jags were down by 40. 

 

And I like Shorts, I just think Crabtree is better. 

---