Name them. 
For the 25th anniversary there are some vids on YouTube and they have it with their ranking and Vic Ketchman and Sam Kavarius. And Brian Sexton

I watched a few videos on YouTube and I put my list under Vinny Manuawia’s video. They have him listed at 18.

I posted my top 25 and even added a few honorable mentions.

Mine would be something like this

Taylor
Boselli
Smith
Brunell
MJD

McCardell
Brackens
Hardy
Nickerson (probably didn’t play as a Jag enough)
Darius

Mathis
Peterson
Walker
Henderson
Stroud

Smeenge
Nickerson
Searcy
Naeole
Beasley

Coleman
Garrard (tough for me to put him but kind of have to)
Kyle Brady or Mitchell depending on era
Scobee or Hollis (I’d go Hollis bc of his playoffs exp)
Natrone Means, However you could put Manuwia there as well. I just can’t say he’s one of the 25 best players in this team’s history.

There are guys like Greg Jones who was just as important to our run game during the down years. How about guys like Lewis who was always our best blocker on the edges. Then there are guys like Daryl Smith and Brad Meester who did it for a long time and was above average for many seasons.

Guys like Linder and Ramsey are knocking on the door and could finish in the top 15 or 20. Heck Ramsey could finish in the top 10.

Then you have Campbell who is one of the best FA signings ever. If he plays another 2 years you have to put him on this list. And you can’t leave out AJ Bouye. The past 2 years he’s given us more than what anybody would have ever guessed. More ints than any player on the team the past 2 seasons. Also in 2017 he was statistically better than Ramsey in a lot of categories. Not bad for an old Texan that came over after the 2016 season.

You could even argue Telvin Smith for what he’s done on defense. Yannick is well on his way to making this list one day if he keeps his current play.

But anyway I’m sure everyone’s list is different after the top 3 players.

---