(09-24-2019, 02:24 PM)Upper Wrote: 1. The jury is still very much out on almost all of those players. Other than Yannick and Ramsey in the good and Fournette in the bad categories we can't really make judgments on any of the others yet.

2. Why not include the Joeckel, Bortles, or Fowler drafts? Caldwell is included in that, and our entire list of players left from those 3 drafts include Linder, Lee, and Cann.

You also have to include ARob, who got away, in #2. 

If you compared Caldwell's drafts to most other GM's drafts, you'd probably see he does better than average. Just within the division, the only GM who's arguably doing better with the draft is the Colts' new guy, but his body of work is limited. Houston whiffs a lot, and Tennessee's last few drafts haven't been any better than Caldwell's. I think I will lay blame for Fournette and Cam Robinson (he still has a chance to be a decent 2nd round pick if he stays healthy moving forward) at Coughlin's feet. I also forgive Caldwell for Joeckel - that was a horrible draft for most everyone. Joeckel seemed to be the safe pick at the time.

---