To be fair, you question the quality of that list of players but ARob, Cam Robinson, Jack and Taylor are all long term starters and border between average to very good. True, a few of them haven't developed (yet) into what we hoped, but it's still a pretty good hit list for the second round of the draft.

As for the strategy I think it's a good one, providing the right player is there of course. It seems like every year there are two things that are always true about the draft: 1. Jags will be picking high 2. At least one widely expected top 20 pick will slide down to the second round. If that player happens to also fit an obvious need Caldwell has shown himself very willing to move up and get him. I like that strategy.

The draft is all about tiers. I remember Dave clearly saying when they drafted ARob he was the last WR available in their top tier of WRs, so they felt the need to go up and get him. Managing the draft is all about managing the tiers, if you can get the last guy in each tier at a position of need then you have got great value.

---