(06-02-2020, 08:40 AM)JaguarKick Wrote:

(06-01-2020, 04:31 PM)iHaunting Raven Wrote: And he is better than that? hahaha what is his record again? with and without Coughlin?
Minshew is a Coughlin's guy, you wanna give it to DC? then Fournette is DC's fault too, and he passed on Mahomes and Watson.

Couple things.  1) Yes, Caldwell is better than both Shack and Gene.  If you don't think that's obvious, I don't know what you're looking at.  A team's record is not necessarily an indicator of the effectiveness of the GM, given how many moving pieces there are to a team.

2) We don't really know the dynamics of who picked who or whatever, but we do know Foles was Coughlin's guy and he forced the issue to start him when he was "healthy."  So I'm not certain that we can really say Minshew was his guy.

He is not better than Shack.

"A team's record is not necessarily an indicator of the effectiveness of the GM" hahaha sure, because you say so. I guess his first HC (Bradley) and his QB (Bortles) are not indicators either.

Caldwell is garbage, period. 

Minshew was his guy as in he drafted him but if you wanna say it was DC then he also drafted Fournette and passed on Mahomes and Watson.

"We don't really know the dynamics of who picked who or whatever" Yes we do thanks to people like you 

Every bad pick = Coughlin
Every good pick = Caldwell lol

Enjoy another losing season.

---