(06-03-2020, 05:27 AM)Hurricane Wrote: I wish i knew the odds of getting "impact" players for each team in the draft. I don't necessarily mean superstars,  but players that play a role and fill a hole atleast average, if not above average.

By looking at the list, it looks like Caldwell averages about 3 impact players a year. I realize some people may classify players differently, so this is just my opinion. But i would like to know how all the other GM's fair compared to this.
We have lived in misery for quite some time with a season here and there shining a bit of hope. Our biggest issue is not getting the Qb position squared away imo. Had Caldwell hit on a Qb early on, i dont think we would be anywhere we currently are. There has been some pretty talented players drafted by us.

---

(06-02-2020, 09:44 PM)iHaunting Raven Wrote: Always fun to read lame excuses for Caldwell.

Keep it going guys, meanwhile our team will have another losing season, just the way you guys like it.

I dont think these are excuses being made. Its more of trying to understand whats went wrong. Can you really look at Caldwells draft and say hes done a horrible job? If so, what and who are you comparing it to? 

Not every post has to be negative.

Again,

What's the team record while he is been here with and without Coughlin? funny how his only winning season he had Coughlin doing his job. 
Hilarious how people love to blame the Khans (absolute ignorants of football) for hiring Bradley. Bradley is Caldwell's first HC, how did it go?
His QB (3rd overall) was absolute garbage

Those 3 are the most important things for a GM, come on now, bring the lame excuses.

---

(06-03-2020, 05:27 AM)Hurricane Wrote: I wish i knew the odds of getting "impact" players for each team in the draft. I don't necessarily mean superstars,  but players that play a role and fill a hole atleast average, if not above average.

By looking at the list, it looks like Caldwell averages about 3 impact players a year. I realize some people may classify players differently, so this is just my opinion. But i would like to know how all the other GM's fair compared to this.
We have lived in misery for quite some time with a season here and there shining a bit of hope. Our biggest issue is not getting the Qb position squared away imo. Had Caldwell hit on a Qb early on, i dont think we would be anywhere we currently are. There has been some pretty talented players drafted by us.

---

(06-02-2020, 09:44 PM)iHaunting Raven Wrote: Always fun to read lame excuses for Caldwell.

Keep it going guys, meanwhile our team will have another losing season, just the way you guys like it.

I dont think these are excuses being made. Its more of trying to understand whats went wrong. Can you really look at Caldwells draft and say hes done a horrible job? If so, what and who are you comparing it to? 

Not every post has to be negative.

Not every post has to be positive just because, without a good reason.

---