Quote:Vick's athleticism made him an athlete, not a QB. Some overrate him as a QB because of his athleticism. What's the excuse for him being so bad on the so-called dream team?

 

 

 

Like I said, I don't judge a QB entirely on his passing ability because that's not the be-all end-all for what makes a good quarterback a good quarterback. For example, I think Peyton Manning is easily the best passer of all-time, however, I think Tom Brady is the better overall quarterback.

 

Vick was a good QB, but he was not a very good passer. I think he was exceptional at compensating for his lack of weapons and subpar passing ability.

 

The "dream team" was bad because it wasn't really that good, and off the top of my head, Maclin was either playing hurt or not playing at all and Desean Jackson taking plays off, and Nnamdi was burnt toast. It was pretty much Vick's Falcons all over again.

---