(11-23-2020, 09:16 PM)Senor Fantastico Wrote:

(11-23-2020, 08:58 PM)TheO-LineMatters Wrote: If you haven't seen them play, how can you form an opinion? I don't ever take anyone else's word on anything. I have to see it for myself. I don't trust consensus. The consensus said that RG3 was gonna be a star QB. The consensus also said JaMarcus Russell was a "can't miss" QB and that Tom Brady was too un-athletic to make it in the NFL. I don't trust the consensus. I like to form my own opinions. 

As for Rudolph, as I said earlier, I did like him am lot and I still do. Unlike other QB's in his class who got drafted to bad teams, he is now sitting behind a future hall of famer who is having an MVP type season. When Rudolph gets his chance to take over the reigns full time, I believe he will be very good. Sitting and learning behind greatness, can only help his progression.

Yeah, you see if for yourself, and you've kinda proven yourself about as accurate as a blind man playing darts over the years. So coming at me with all this I scout these guys in the filmroon myself junk is beyond laughable.

I'm certainly not right all the time and have never claimed to be. I've made a lot of mistakes over the years, but I've got a better track record than Caldwell. Heck, over half of this board could make better picks than he has. I did say that DaVon Hamilton was our best pick in the last draft and well............. so far, I'm looking pretty good.

---

(11-23-2020, 09:43 PM)Upper Wrote:

(11-23-2020, 05:59 PM)TheO-LineMatters Wrote: LOL. You can pick and choose plays here and there for any player and put together a clip to make them look good. You're only picking the best plays. I could pick and choose throws from JaMarcus Russell's career and make him look like a hall of famer. It's all about consistency in a single game and to do that, you have to watch games in their entirety.

I'm not picking and choosing highlight plays. I'm picking and choosing plays (actually that guy did since it is addressing the flaws you and others claim he had coming into the year) that directly shows him displaying the skills that you say he doesn't have. But you refuse to even read the article or watch the clip so it's pointless to keep going.

I'm talking about consistency. Yes, he will do things on occasion that look good, but he doesn't do them consistently like a franchise QB should. He is wildly inconsistent. It's not that hard, I don't know why you don't understand this? Let's just agree to disagree and move on.

---