(12-29-2021, 10:48 AM)NewJagsCity Wrote:

(12-29-2021, 09:04 AM)MIJagsFan Wrote: I dont like the idea of bringing in a OC with a HOF QB, You don't know who's responsible for the success. Look at KC, all everyone was talking about the past couple of years was how great Mahomes is, while he's good, I think its Andy Reid. Reid seems to always get the most out of his QB's. Now that Bieniemy is calling the plays, Mahomes doesn't look the same. Why have people been calling for Bieniemy to get a HC gig? Same thing goes for Hackett and Leftwich, I am not saying these guys can't be good HC's but why? If you have an amazing QB does it really matter who the OC is? I would look for the OC's who make their QBs look better, who get the most out of them, like Reid. Find me an OC with an average QB doing great things, that's the guy that I want. Not the OC with a great QB doing amazing things. Take Caldwell, he did things with an average to above average QB in Detroit, or Pederson who had an average qb in both Wentz and Foles. Those are the guys who have done things.

Agree on Caldwell, but Reich was the reason for Wentz/Foles.  Case in point is Indy this year.

Not to crap on your parade of redistributing credit, but Reich left the eagles after their Superbowl, and Wentz had a couple of more decent seasons there after Reich left. Foles also had a decent season there after he left ( got the eagles into the playoffs, again).

Reich has had success in Indy, but Pedersen and the QBs did just fine after he left, too.

---