Login

TheO-LineMatters · 02-12-2022, 01:05 AM

(02-12-2022, 12:52 AM)Bullseye Wrote:
(02-11-2022, 10:17 PM)Caldrac Wrote: This seemed to be pretty popular last spring, so let's do it again this year.

I would propose the following rule change: Once you give your answer and reasoning, you have to pick the next pair to present to the board to choose from.

Pick 70 or 104 Christian Watson or Khalil Shakir

Caldrac...

Quote:Yes to both players. I like them both. Watson has great size and range. Shakir is shifty and can zoom at times with short catches. We need to get better at WR for sure this off season. These two guys offer great value in this scenario. If I can only have one? I take Watson due to his size and range.

Pick 70 or Pick 97. Chad Muma or Charlie Kolar.

Regarding Watson vs. Shakir, it's a battle vs size and separation vs. shiftiness and the spectacular acrobatic catch. In this scenario, I take Watson, though my gut tells me he may be gone by pick 70. In fact I'm think he could go in the 2nd round by th time the draft rolls around

Pick 70 or 97 Chad Muma or Charlie Kolar

Muma for me. This is a decision between two guys at schools that typically don't produce many good pros. Kolar gets the edge in terms of fitting a need, but when I finally saw Muma, I came awat very impressed. He has very good instincts for the position and is always arund the ball. He combines those instincts with very good athleticism and hustle. If the Jaguars took him, he would help our 3-4 a great deal.

Next choice: Pick 33 Zion Johnson vs. Tre McBride.

Personally, I take Watson over Shakir, by the slightest of margins. Both would be good pickups, but ultimately, I believe Watson is just a slightly better route runner.

I easily take Chad Muma over Charlie Kolar. I like Kolar, but there are other TE's I like better. Muma is just a beast and we have a HUGE need at ILB. I'm hoping we trade Myles Jack for another draft pick and someone like Muma who is great against the run and the pass would be a huge upgrade.

I take Tre McBride over Zion Johnson. McBride is a big play TE who is almost as good as having another receiver out there. He is definitely my #1 TE. I really like Johnson as well, but with his lack of size, he is a pure OG. I know he played some Center during the Senior Bowl, but didn't look very comfortable there. I prefer my O-Linemen to be experienced at multiple positions.

Next Choice: WR Romeo Doubs vs. TE Isaiah Likely