Quote:i agree though when someones opinion doesnt have a stellar track record regarding qbs, its hard to take that opinion seriously.

 

I don't think anybody compared Geno Smith to Andrew Luck though.  Not many people said he was a sure thing either.  People liked Geno because he put up big numbers.  Not because of anything he showed.  Most people saw him as little more than a starter.  And remember everyone here got excited over Matt Scott too -- so the Geno love was a result of QB deficiency in a year with no good prospects coming out.  I do however remember a user saying he wanted Bridgewater as early as last year, that didn't want anything to do with Geno Smith.  

---