Quote:But if I cant pick Rob Johnson based on who he turned into and had to do it based on their actual play, I'd go with Garrard.  Even though he was an average at best starting QB, he was a starting QB nonetheless.  He was essentially the equal of Leftwich who we grabbed in the first.  Definitely an increase in value.  And obviously the most important position.

 

I always had a soft spot for Seth Payne.  Eventually turned into a starter for us during our peak time in the late 90s.  Was sad to see him leave and head off to Houston.  Started there but injuries caught up to him a little.

 

Two guys not on your list, I wanted to give a shout out to... Reggie Barlow and Tavian Banks.... Barlow was one of those few guys who was good at both punt and kick returns.  And Tavian Banks was about to turn into a really good player until a bad injury ended his career.  He has always been the "what if" guy in our history if you ask me.  (Also, I think his draft pick came from that Rob Johnson trade as well)