Quote:This sounds silly. But other than two playoff runs, I don't think Eli has ever been a great QB. It sounds silly because he has two Super Bowl rings, both over Tom Brady. 

 

But he has under a 60% comp percentange for his career and has only once gone over 30 TD's in the golden era of passing.

 

I know what you mean. Eli's just an average, to a little above average QB most seasons, who does just happen to have to Super Bowl wins on his resume.

 

He did lead his team to the playoffs 5 times though and has an 8-3 record in the playoffs as a starting QB. He's 0-3, three of those times and 8-0 in the 2 SB runs.

 

If Eli wins that 1st playoff game, he goes on to win the SB.

 

As of right now, he can always remind Peyton that he has 2 rings to his one.

 

Who's career would you take Eli with his 2 SB rings or Peyton?

 

 

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/pl...nnEl00.htm

---