Quote:Pro bowls he wasn't even voted into. David Garrard is a pro bowler too then!


Good awards...shall I list the top qbs to compare to?...

 

Passer rating Career:

 

Luck 86.6

Manning 97.5 (including much harder passing era. 107 in Denver)

Brady 95.9

Rodgers 106

Rothlisberger 93.9

Garrard 85.8

Gabbert 66.8

Brees 95.4

Rivers 95.7

 

You see why he is overrated while being a good player? He's not as good as the guys he's compared to

 

 

Luck was compared to Manning coming out and has performed better than Manning through the first three seasons of their careers.

 

For the record I think Manning is better but Luck has the potential to be one of the best. I think that's all anyone is saying. Only time will tell.

 

Also the Rating can be misleading because Luck is only in his 3rd year whereas the other guys have 2-3x + as many seasons.

 

I think if you were to redo the list with everyone's rating after 3 seasons it would look different.

---