Quote:I feel like you didn't actually watch Blackmon.. he's a good wr and imo would benefit this team greatly to have back, but he was very inconsistent.. he never made the "tough" catches he never went up and caught a difficult pass, he was a YAC wr who was good at getting open in the intermediate game. That 200 yard game was special, but let's not act like he didn't have 160+ yards of YAC. 

Inconsistency from rookies is the norm not the exception.

 

When you evaluate a young player you shouldn't focus on the inconsistency but rather focus on what they are capable of when they put a complete game together.

 

Robinson's complete games have been solid. Blackmon's complete games have been dominant.

 

I've watched every game played by both as a pro. There is no doubt in my mind that Blackmon's ceiling his much higher than Robinson's.

 

That doesn't mean that I don't think Robinson can't be a very good receiver, he just hasn't flashed superstar the way Blackmon has on multiple occasions.

---