Quote:Which is the wrong mindset. You said the goal is to put the most talented players on the field. You can't even remotely say that right now because 1) Thomas is valued higher than Lewis (so no reason why you have Lewis in there instead of him) 2) we don't know who our FB is because we don't have one.

 

The comparison you have of Robinson, Lee, Lewis, and a FB is not a good comparison. The one I presented of 2WR/2TE is a much better comparison, for the reasons I stated. So, as I framed from my previous post...

 

We line up with Robinson and Lee split wide. Julius in the slot as our move, and Lewis as a traditional TE.

 

You're the Defensive coordinator of the opposing team. What formation do you run?

 

Go.

 

What are you talking about? I said I forgot to list Thomas on the second lineup. Marcedes should never be in a lineup over Thomas, even if it's a power run formation. Thomas should be in on every down. What we're really doing is arguing over Marcedes being better or worse than having the 3rd WR on the field and a single back or having the 2nd WR on the field and a FB. In either case I'd say it's much more valuable to have the WR on the field than Marcedes unless it's a goal line definite power run situation.

---