Quote:If you cannot tell the difference between Luck taking over a terrible team and making them a playoff team, vs Wilson joining one of the best teams in the league, than that's a you problem.

 

That's all great, I'm speaking from a perspective of simply watching both players, you're right, Luck does have a smaller margin of error because of the team he's on, but to discredit Wilson because he's on a better team is ridiculous. What does Lucks defense have to do with his completion percentage? What does Lucks defense have to do with his YPA? If you want to talk about a supporting cast, Reggie Wayne, T.Y. Hilton, & Coby Fleener are better options than Sidney Rice, Golden Tate, and Zach Miller, Wilson has played most of the season without his starting left and right tackles, and the backups have been atrocious. When I watch Wilson (and Luck), I see two QB's that elevate the level of play of the players around them, not the opposite, I believe (and the numbers support it) Wilson does it on a more consistent basis.

---