Lets keep all this in prospective. Every GM has mis-plays. The good GM's are the one's who ultimately pick a top 10 QB. Check.

 

Forsett? Oops

Gutting the roster with too much youth? Painful start but could pay off with a ring. Id rather avg 3 wins then make the jump to the superbowl within 6 years than avg 7 and become an early exit playoff team every year.

Joeckel? Worst draft class in decades and he picks the only guy who hasn't completely busted yet. (AKA the best guy in the top 5 in that draft), So this IMO is actually a credit to him. 

Toby? I don't think anyone forsaw what happened there. 

Gus? Lets see what happens this season before we seal the letter on this one.

Lewis?  Could be an AMAZING backup actually. 

Lee? Could be his first true high value bust but I'd rather a GM who swings for the fences. He tried to completely fix the offense in one season and for the most part did that. Lee would've just been icing on the cake.

 

Remember, This guy got Hurns, Robinson, T. Smith, Marks, Cann, Linder, A. Colvin, and the most important player who will determine our fate, Blake Bortles. He's our guy and so is Caldwell. There could be some hall of fame players in that list. 

---