Quote:It's not so much that it was just one year for ARob as much as it is the other top five contenders having proven themselves year after year. I just don't think you crack that list after only one season.


 

Speaking of great one-year seasons, we might also need to consider just how good the Panthers Kelvin Benjamin might be this year after missing his sophomore season. He could very well be in this discussion.

 

I'm fine with someone not putting him in the top 5. When you start asking things like Larry Fitzgerald and Jordy Nelson (at this point in their careers) better than Robinson then that's where Robinson starts getting too undervalued.

 

No, I think Benjamin's ceiling is topped at around the Keenan Allen level. I don't think he will ever be a top 5 candidate.

 

 

Also, as much as I dislike OBJ, putting him 8th on your list is criminal. The guy is averaging over 100 yards per game and nearly 1 TD per game in his first two seasons. Those are crazy numbers.

---