Quote:Who's making stuff up, we had this discussion years ago. The giants have a committee selection and personal just like the jags did under shack and JDR. Some teams like us under Caldwell and Smith divide the roles and have GM's exclusively in charge or personel.


You asked would a better coach do more with this roster. The two examples you used would cut half this team tommorrow. I'm pretty sure Gus doesn't have that autonomy at least I can't remember the last time some one screwed up and was cut the next day, you've seen coughlin do it do obviously he had more of a role in personel.


This roster sucks, bring in any coach I don't care who Bortles wind up isn't changing. Yeldon doesn't suddenly become mjd. The line isn't all of the sudden rock solid. Maybe Ramsey and Fowler stop looking like idiots?

The two examples I used wouldn't have half the issues Gus currently has. The players do whatever they want because Gus has absolutely no respect in the locker room. This has been plainly obvious the past few weeks from Odrick, to Ramsey, to Fowler, to Jackson to the league leading penalties. Those coaches demand respect and a player wouldn't dare do what they are currently doing freelancing and playing with no control. Do you think the players are out in practice getting better and learning their craft everyday? THE ENTIRE TEAM IS REGRESSING ON A WEEKLY BASIS. You wonder why the players look bad? It's not for lack of talent.

---