(02-16-2019, 09:05 AM)JackCity Wrote:

(02-16-2019, 05:16 AM)lastonealive Wrote: That's incorrect. luck was 10-12 from 2015-2017. He improved to 10-6 in 2018 with a good run game a great oline and a good D. He has also thrown 56 picks in his last 54 starts and has thrown more interceptions than tds in the playoffs averaging 1.5 picks a game. He certainly isn't noticeably better than the group listed.

He beat up the afc south when it was garbage his first couple of years and struggled against everyone else.

You forgot to include the other years, you know, the ones where he wasn't badly injured. 

Your Andrew Luck = Andy Dalton is a very interesting hill to die on. Delusional but interesting nonetheless.

Andy Dalton has completed 62.3 percent at 7.2 yards an attempt at 88.8 rating.

Luck has completed 60.8 percent at 7.2 yards an attempt at 89.5

The difference is draft and followup hype. They are both awful in the playoffs so have that in common too.

Thought I would add a couple more top 10qbs and not be unfair with a Brady brees or Rogers...

Big Ben 64.4 percent at 7.8 yards an attempt and 94.2 rating
Rivers 64.5 at 7.8 yards an attempt and 95.6 rating

Pretty clear difference.

---