Caldwell is average overall.
Flashes of "really good" with mid-late picks and UDFA, but flashes of bad in the frrst round.
His FA signings are pretty well divided between hits and misses but such is the nature of FA and many of the "misses" ended up in that column due to injury to the player.

The hate toward the guy is usually either poorly informed, hyperbolized, or lacking perspective on the league average performance by GMs.

I assumed he 'd be gone this year and I was OK with that. I could understand why, but I like what he's done on paper this offseason aside from passing on a LT. We'll see...

---