(06-18-2022, 10:50 PM)Upper Wrote: Sorry but Robinson and ETN are definitely not better than Antonio Gibson and JD McKissic. Brian Robinson is a damn good RB3 too.

It's arguable. The injuries are why this is uncertain. The early reports point to a full recovery for both players.

But for arguments sake, let's say they do make a full recovery. Comparing Robinson and Gibson is a little problematic because they have such different styles. Statistically, they are very similar with Robinson a little bit better in almost every statistical category and that's with the inexplicable benching he dealt with due to Meyer's ineptitude last year. He also has remarkable vision and a nose for getting tough yards. in 2021, Robinson was 4.7 ypc where Gibson was at 4.0. Gibson seems more like a scat back to me. As far as JD McKissic, he's as much receiver as running back. Basically he's just a guy. Etienne is a uniquely explosively player who had to deal with a major injury last year but should be considerably better than a journeyman.

As far as RB3, if you have to go that far down the depth chart you're in trouble but Snoop Conner has been turning heads in the mini-camps so I hear. I haven't watched him outside of his college highlights. I'd say he and Brian Robinson are a wash.

Edge: Jags (assuming they're healthy which is the wildcard here)

---