It is partly on him. Although many were not his fault, he could not lead the NFL in interceptions last year without making some mistakes.

Ok JDub, you lost me again.

---

Yeah, I guess it was more the D in those 2 SBs then the offense, although Eli did have to make a few great throws to get it done.

 

He does have 5 playoff game-winning drives though, and that's all Eli and the offense.

That is true.  Fans in the age of Madden and fantasy football are so heavy on stats, in the NFL, especially the post season, it's the clutch QB that makes the difference between championships and going home early.

---

5 picks yesterday. I really think he's done.

---

"Before you criticize a man, walk a mile in his shoes. That way, if he gets angry, he's a mile away and barefoot."

He's never been that good.  He was good/great at the right key moments but he's never been a top of the league guy or if he was it was not for very long. I like Eli, good guy but he's as inconsistent as it gets.  He brought the Giants a couple Super Bowls and made great plays in those games though.  I think he and Coughlin are both out after this year and we see a clean out of sorts in New York.

---

He's never been that good.  He was good/great at the right key moments but he's never been a top of the league guy or if he was it was not for very long. I like Eli, good guy but he's as inconsistent as it gets.  He brought the Giants a couple Super Bowls and made great plays in those games though.  I think he and Coughlin are both out after this year and we see a clean out of sorts in New York.

 

This

---

He's never been that good.  He was good/great at the right key moments but he's never been a top of the league guy or if he was it was not for very long. I like Eli, good guy but he's as inconsistent as it gets.  He brought the Giants a couple Super Bowls and made great plays in those games though.  I think he and Coughlin are both out after this year and we see a clean out of sorts in New York.

 

Pretty much. He's like the Hillary Swank of the NFL. Mostly mediocre performances but two trophies.

---

;

;

He will proably throw for 300+ yards and four TDs against us!

---