I saw this on ESPN today and its obvious we've reached the slow season. But the question remains, is Brady still a top 5 QB? Who would be your top 5?

---

"Before you criticize a man, walk a mile in his shoes. That way, if he gets angry, he's a mile away and barefoot."

1.  Aaron Rodgers

2.  Tom Brady

3,  Peyton Manning

4,  Drew Brees

5,  Andrew Luck

---

1.  Aaron Rodgers

2.  Tom Brady

3,  Peyton Manning

4,  Drew Brees

5,  Andrew Luck

1. Manning

2. Rodgers

3. Brees

4. Brady

5. Big Ben

6. Rivers

---

Coughlin when asked if winning will be a focus: "What the hell else is there? This is nice and dandy, but winning is what all this is about."

Stupid question

---

1. Manning

2. Rodgers

3. Brees

4. Brady

5. Big Ben

6. Rivers

Manning at 1? Biggest postseason choke artist ever

---

1. Manning

2. Brady

3. Rodgers

4. Brees

5. Rivers

---

Manning at 1? Biggest postseason choke artist ever

 

I would take a team that consistently wins and has that shot to win in the postseason than a lot of qb's out there.

---

Manning at 1? Biggest postseason choke artist ever

 

And he still belongs on the list as a top 5 QB.

 

 

1.Brees

2. Manning

3. Rodgers

4. Brady

5. Rivers 

---

Manning at 1? Biggest postseason choke artist ever

 

when it comes down to it though, the majority of the games are played in the regular season and he is just the best there is. just on another level. 

---

Coughlin when asked if winning will be a focus: "What the hell else is there? This is nice and dandy, but winning is what all this is about."

Brady with weapons is #1, Brady with his current roster is number #4.

 

1. Brees

2. Rodgers

3. Manning

4. Brady

5. Manning

---

“An empty vessel makes the loudest sound, so they that have the least wit are the greatest babblers.”. - Plato

My turn:


Rodgers

Brees

Manning

Brady

Luck

---

I'll take Rodgers over any of them. 

 

then

 

2. Brady

3. Manning

4. Brees

5. Big Ben/Rivers

---

Benefit of doubt (after a off year), I would say he is a top 5 QB.  He'll probably have 2 to 3 years at the elite top 5 level with one of the years being a trademark Tom Brady is better than Manning and is GOAT year.  Then a couple of off years before he retires.  I can't see him playing after 5 to 6 more seasons.

 

Guys who are top 5 no matter what list:  Manning, Brees, Rodgers.  The 5th spot would go to Luck/Rivers/Eli.  To say two of the fringe guys are better than Brady would be pushing it.  Kaep and Wilson are knocking on the door as well, but they have great coaches and talent around them so their short period of success doesn't weigh heavy against Brady.

---

Brady

Brees

Manning

Rodgers


Top 4 in no particular order. These guys are always consistently elite no matter their weapons. Everyone else is in a lower category


Edit: I actually think it's Belichick that's holding Brady back right now. I think Belichick is getting near the Andy Reid type situation he had in Philly.

---

1.) Manning

2.) Aaron Rodgers

3.) Tom Brady

4.) Drew Brees

5.) Ben

---

1.) Brady

2.) Manning

3.) Brees

4.) Rodgers

5.) Ben

---

And he still belongs on the list as a top 5 QB.

 

 

1.Brees

2. Manning

3. Rodgers

4. Brady

5. Rivers 

When did I say he didn't?  Cmon Ninja, I think you can read better than that!

---

I would take a team that consistently wins and has that shot to win in the postseason than a lot of qb's out there.

I agree but he is not over Rodgers or Brady IMO.  If they were on that Den team the SB would of been a lot closer if didnt win it.

---

I agree but he is not over Rodgers or Brady IMO.  If they were on that Den team the SB would of been a lot closer if didnt win it.

 

That's hard to say. Seattle had a great team.

---

Yes.




Next question.

---

What in the Wide Wide World of Sports is agoin' on here???