Quote:Everything you've said so far is based on a hypothetical situation.  I mean, it's great that you think you'd have done so much better; that's a really unique viewpoint to find on the internet and all. 

 

But you have no idea what the Jags would look like right now if they'd done exactly what you describe.   You have no idea whether keeping the players you described would have lead to a better team right now, much less a better team 3 years from now. 

 

What we do know is that team produced 2 wins and needed massive changes.  And evidently that you would have done it differently.  Great, thanks for the info. 

 

I've stated that IMO trading a top 10 LT for third day picks is a horrible move and reeks of someone being in over his head. You want to take it personal fine, but go ahead and tell me with a straight face we're better off with Geno Hayes instead of Daryl Smith......

 

Quote:Lets fire the guy before he has a chance!  Lets all jump to conclusions. 

 

I would love to see the Jaguars become a playoff contender in a couple years.  I will bookmark this and point out everyone that just railed against him.

 

I'm not saying he is going to be an amazing GM, heck, he could be Gene Smith all over again....but to react like this so quickly is beyond me.  Then again, its par for the course for the mb.

 

I haven't seen anyone suggest firing the guy? I've seen a few not many that are concerned with some of the moves Caldwell is making, this being one of the big ones.

 

I would love for the Jags to become playoff contenders, but trading away top 10 talent at a premium position for 3rd day picks is risky business in the least.

---