Alls I know is Josh Allen was terrible in college and got drafted because of his height weight and arm strength.
McCarron was pretty good in college, hell maybe the last real QB Bama had (cept Tua gonna kill it this year) and he never could get a shot in cincy and is seemingly behind in Buffalo. Perhaps its an arm strength issue...
Peterman... IDK man... he's a former 5th round project. If he's your lead dude... you should have never got rid of Tyrod.

Peterman likely has the head up because he's the only QB that was there last year.
I imagine by season start McCarron or Allen will be starting.

Ideally it would be Allen. I mean... why else would you draft a guy in the first round?
But I think he'll take a lot longer to come around than the Bills planned.

If I'm coach... And it is close with these 3 guys... I start McCarron. And hold out as long as possible before putting Allen in (somewhere around mid season if the record is 2-6 or something).
I think Buffalo messed up not having a good veteran to lean on either like Henne or even a McCown guy.
I think they messed up by drafting Allen altogether... but perhaps he eventually becomes a mentally strong QB and not just another strong arm.

Buffalo is taking a big step back this year from their playoff team just last season, imo.

---