(11-17-2018, 06:00 PM)Upper Wrote:

(11-17-2018, 05:47 PM)JackCity Wrote: Hmmm I must say I don't see any of them. Maybe Jones and Allen with the big frames and mobility, big arms and do their best work out of structure, both bad Vs pressure and meh production

I see Mayfield and Herbert as extremely efficient guys who can make plays with their feet but are still pass first guys. Rosen and Jones are kind of what you see is good, but that's about all you're going to get. I think they are both sound fundamentally/mechanically and don't need too much coaching to be ready to go. I also don't see a ton of room for growth with either. Haskins and Jones are both big armed, big upside, and athletic...but raw and shouldn't start right away. They definitely aren't body/size comps.

Style wise Grier would fit the Mayfield comp a lot better than Herbert.  Uber efficient undersized QBs with elite placement   albeit Griers arm is a notch below Mayfields (and overall talent). Both pretty mobile but not really scramblers.

The Rosen/Jones makes more sense that way I guess but Jones is still pretty raw in a lot of areas and stands to improve a lot in the NFL Vs at Duke.

---