(12-24-2018, 11:01 AM)NYC4jags Wrote:

(12-24-2018, 10:52 AM)flgatorsandjags Wrote: Kinda have a feeling Lock and Herbert are the 2 guys that kill the combine and Grier and Haskins take a bit of a hit.  Could be wrong though

That wouldn't shock me at all.  Very possible. 

I could be way off on this, but my guy tells me Herbert will need refinement at the league level sort of like what Josh Allen is going through. (Herbert is a little more accurate than Allen of course)
Lock will be more accurate as well, but I feel his ability to drop back and go through a progression is a huge unknown right now. I'd feel better about him if I had any confidence in his ability to do that.  

As it is, I think all four of these guys can be NFL starters. It's just a matter of how quickly they'll make the transition and be efficient in a pro offense.

Agree on Herbert, he might have the most upside but also the most raw.  Agree with pretty much everything you said though.  I think this years the 2019 QB class will be a lot like this years as in they wont look good year 1 but you will see spurts of the potential and talent but just not the consistency like this year other than Mayfield.  I think this years QB class is a bit underrated but I do think having them sit a year or at least half a years would be best for all 4 of the top QBs. Haskins and Grier I think could possibly start mid season though and possibly Lock.  If we draft Herbert though I would def. like to see him sit the whole year but he could kill it in year 2 though.  If Mahomes started last year I dont think he would of been nowhere near as good, some QBs just need to sit that first year.

---