(11-27-2018, 04:50 PM)Jords808 Wrote:

(11-27-2018, 11:40 AM)Kane Wrote: So is Herbert coming out or not? When I include him people tell me he is staying in school. When I don't, people include him in their list lol.
Obviously if he comes out he's up there. Although personally I'm actually not as big on Herbert as others. He's a guy that reminds me of the Josh Allen love. Yeah he has the "tools" but does he actually make it work? His comp % from game to game is wildly all over the place.
I think returning to school is probably a good idea for Herbert. Although if he's pegged as a first round top 5 talent, not really sure why he would.
Haskins has been hot and cold for me. Some games I think he's the best QB propect and others I'm not sure he is a first round QB. With the right coach staff though he could be real good.
Lock and Grier are very much 1a 1b. for me both have some stuff to work on to be great at the next level but I think they are the most ready to start out of any of the QBs.

The rest of the guys are 2nd, 3rd and late rounders imo. Finley is Falk this year for me. I was high on him going into the season and as the season goes on I cool on him considerably.
Falk ended up in the 5th round iirc... I think Finley is more of a 2nd or 3rd now. But I've seen mocks having him go late in round 1 to the Pats...... so we'll see I guess.

I do not get the love Lock gets and im gonna kind of vent here.

Youre hot and cold on Haskins but think Lock is 1a????? Haskins worst games was Nebraska and Penn state, both at 56% with multiple tds and 1 pick in each game..btw won both games

Locks in a 3 game stretch against Georgia 47% 0 tds 1 pick, S Car 47% 0 tds 2 picks, Bama 50% 1 td 2 picks... lost all 3. He is definition of "hot and cold" more cold than hot

The only lost OSU has vs Purdue, Haskins still went off...470 yrds 67% 2 tds and 1 pick

Haskins is setting records in every category behind a TRASH line.... btw he jus DESTROYED Michigan defense which was one of the best defenses, only behind Bama. 396 yrds 67% 6 tds and 0 picks.

Please elaborate on your "Cold" moments Haskins has

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

Do you feel better now that you vented?

Here's the thing when looking at stats like that, you're not using your eyes. You're not watching how the QB performs with the tools around him. You're not looking at the competition.
As per a QB ready to start right away ready for the NFL, yeah Grier and Lock are my guys. Haskins looks great when not under pressure. And early on I didn't even have him on my radar, then I watched some OSU games coming away pretty impressed. Then I saw a few games where it looked like Haskins was Blaine Gabberting under pressure (wth that trash OL). Then he tore up Michigan. Which was pretty cool to see. I'm sorry I hurt your feelings putting your favorite QB 2nd on my list. (considering I have a 1a and 1b)
I think the UGA and Bama defenses are better than anything Haskins has seen (yet). We'll see how he does if he makes it into the CFP. 
I don't know if you just wanted to knee jerk react to my post or what, but I actually would be happy drafting Haskins and certainly wasn't bagging on him.

None of these QB prospects are perfect... everyone is gonna have their flavor. I watch about as much college ball as possible every Saturday. Not just my Gators. Not just SEC.
I even stay up late sometimes to catch Pac12 games.
I don't just look at stats. And I don't get all in my feelings about any particular player really. I think Grier is the best QB prospect, I like Lock almost as much, and then there is Haskins.

Don't travel over to CBS Sports for Chris Trapasso's QB analysis if you're easily upset.
They have Haskins below Lock as well.... as the 5th QB in his stock watch article.
Lock is 1st (above Herbert and Grier and Haskins)

(They have Finley 2nd for some strange reason)

---