(06-07-2019, 01:14 PM)JackCity Wrote:

(06-07-2019, 11:40 AM)NYC4jags Wrote: LOL 

We're determining whether another human's opinions are worthy of one's respect or not.  
It's not a "fallacy."  
It's a judgement call. Unique to each individual.

There's no absolute in respecting one man's opinion over another's.  And there's no concrete outcome. 

"I think this guy  has a better chance of being right than this other guy." 

It's not rocket science. And authority has [BLEEP] all to do with it.

---

I think everyone worthy of debating with here is using on field performance as a primary determination. 

I simply find your casual dismissal of Dungy's take a bit odd. For reasons I've already made clear.

Again its not about Dungy or his take specifically, just that using a former coaches media take on a player over their track record wouldn't be wise.

No has one suggested doing that.  And my questioning to you absolutely was about Dungy and his take. 
You're just choosing to lump him in with all of the other  "old former coaches."  I prefer to look at each of them individually. 

All we've arrived at here is:
You don't respect Dungy's take as much as I do. He's just another old former coach.  I was curious about that. Not a big deal. 
 Moving on...

---