(06-14-2019, 01:58 PM)HURRICANE!!! Wrote:

(06-14-2019, 11:31 AM)NYC4jags Wrote: Yeah, but why? 

I mean, McNair clearly means/represents something different to the titans organization and fanbase than Garrard does to ours. 

That's why his number is being retired. 

Are we supposed to bash those fans for having a sentimentality over one of the better QBs they've had?

I was being sarcastic.  I actually posted their stats showing they were dramatically different but you cut that off when you quoted my post.

Then you don't get what sarcasm is. Your int stats for McNair were wrong, but otherwise the point is on a per pass basis they were practically the same, just that McNair had twice as many attempts. Though Garrard's stats we actually better per pass and he was more clutch if you think game winning drives and comeback wins mean anything.

McNair is a great example of getting too much credit for what his team did.

What would the opinion of him be if the "lateral" against the bills in '99 were correctly called a forward pass and the titans went one and done?

---