(07-20-2019, 07:19 AM)iHaunting Raven Wrote:

(07-16-2019, 11:51 AM)jaglou53 Wrote: 1. Fred Taylor
2. Tony Boselli
3. Jimmy Smith

4. Mark Brunell
5. MJD
6. Calais Campbell
7. Jaylen Ramsay
8. Keenan McCardell
9. Tony Brackens

10. Marcus Stroud
11. Rasshean Mathis
12. Kevin Hardy
13. Paul Poslusny
14. Darryl Smith
15. Greg Jones
16. Brad Meester
17.Leon Searcy
18. Mike Peterson
19. Donovan Darius
20. Mercedes Lewis
21. Telvin Smith
22. John Henderson
23. Josh Scobee
24. Vince Manuwai
25. Joel Smengee


I grouped mine in 3 tiers. The top 3 players all have a strong case for number 1 of all-time. I gave it to Fred since his career was longer and he was highly under-rated by the national media. Some may question my ranking Calais and Ramsay too high at this point. Regardless, both deserve their rankings due to their dominance at their positions. Campbell may have had the greatest single season in Jaguars history- certainly on the defensive side of the ball.

Stroud was more popular around the league but Henderson was better.

Agreed. Henderson seemed just to a tad bit more dominant and consistent at times. I ranked him just ahead of Stroud. Which was not easy being a Georgia Bulldogs fan and him being a Tennessee Volunteer. 

They were fun as hell to watch when I was a kid. That's why I gave Rob Meier a nod of respect on my list as well. He was a solid rotational player and overachieved for his draft status during those years. I almost added Gary Walker and Seth Payne over the kickers but Hollis was the all-time leading scorer here for awhile until Scobee came along. 

And Scobee also had some amazing kicks to finish some games for us. Long distance kicks. I know he fell off a cliff here and went out to a lot of boo birds but he's still one of my favorite personalities we ever had here during a lull of terrible teams.

---