(07-23-2019, 10:57 AM)jaglou53 Wrote:

(07-23-2019, 12:39 AM)NYC4jags Wrote: I find it odd when players who had their career cut short by injury make someone's "worst" list.  
Seems at least a bit unfair, and at worst ill-informed.
Listing players who were undrafted and signed dirt cheap seems weird to me as well.

---

My top Jags list is basically Fred Taylor followed by 24 other dudes that we could all shift around in rankings and debate about for a week. 

My worst list is basically 95% of the players associated with Gene Smith.

To be clear, my list was comprised of players whose time in Jacksonville created the most disappointment in our fans. Tavian Banks, in his very brief career, showed signs that he could become an exciting and productive player. He demonstrated rare skills and his injury was extremely unfortunate. The same with Cheever. 

Lists like this are subjective and fun ways to kill time during the boring off-season. I clarified my criterion as "most disapponting" rather than "worst." You are entitled to your opinion, but to call my list "unfair, ill-informed and weird" is way too harsh.