(09-11-2019, 12:21 AM)Eric1 Wrote:

(09-10-2019, 11:54 PM)JackCity Wrote: If this roster had Watson/Mahomes or even Lamar we'd be talking about it as a perennial division winner. Hell, even Derek Carr would have had us significantly more competitive over the course of his deal. 

You just can't keep missing at the position and keep your job. And idc if that's Caldwell or Coughlin, both have failed miserably

And

How did he keep missing though? He took one shot at drafting a QB high.. It didn't pan out. You really can't count a bunch of 6th round QBs as trying and trying at the position.

But with that said, what if Minshew becomes the man, plays great and is the future of this franchise moving forward. How would that change things in your guy's eyes about Caldwell and him taking QBs..

Because he had multiple chances to take new QBs and missed on them all. Not taking a QB when you badly need one is a miss. 

Their big solution to all of this was an injury prone and inconsistent big money QB, and low and behold he doesn't last 12 snaps. 

If Minshew becomes a consistent franchise QB I'd be more than happy albeit would have questions about why it took 6 years to get there.

---