If he was just a scout and drafter, I was say he is average BUT he is the GM. Our overall record is the biggest reason and not being able to keep the good players that he drafted.

I really feel like half of the board could produce similar results with the amount of years Caldwell has had. Trial and error, if you have 7 years and don't get better then there is something wrong. The 1 good year we had, Coughlin was in control. So overall as a GM he is below average. Stop trying justify what could have went different or speculations of what caused what, look at our RESULTS.

He is great at negotiations because he should.have been fired in year 4 or 5 the latest but he was able to talk Shad into keeping him. He might go somewhere and be a great GM because of all of the experience he has had with us but there is no way to prove that he has even been average. Lets wake up and hold coaches and the front office accountable, not just the players.

---