(06-23-2020, 11:29 PM)jaguarmvp Wrote: Caldwell is not and never will be a competent GM.  I give him credit for scouting in the latter rounds.   Do people have stockholm syndrome or something?  

This roster has stunk for the major majority of his time here.    He decided to hit the nuclear button when he got here and kicked off some very capable people.  Daryl Smith and Monroe are just 2 examples.   Is it not a reality the only successful year we have had since Caldwell has joined the jags was the year Coughlin was his boss?   OH and if you want to give Caldwell credit for the roster then give him credit for how bad it is now.  For people who do not have teal glasses on, this team is a 2 to 6 win team.  This roster is once again bare and we just booted off the last of the remaining talent.  

So now this team is rebuilding yet again.  We won't get into the fact of the Bortles debacle and the many first round picks.   The guy is a decent scout, not GM materials.   We will be looking for another GM in a year or two.  You can quote me on that.

I think you are being a bit dramatic with how "untalented" the roster has been since he came here. We have actually had some pretty good talent. I think Caldwells biggest issue has been with seeing the weak points and fixing them before they became huge problems. Granted alot of situations haven't made things any easier such as seasons where alot of key players ended up injured. Then throw in Telvin Smiths issue, Ramseys issue and now Yannick. Those 3 players are a huge hit on this team, then throw in the swing and miss on Bradley and Bortles. Its definitely hurt him as a GM. I know every GM faces some adversity and has to rise above. Caldwell hasn't done the best job at doing that. 

Hopefully since Khan has decided to give him another chance, he can get things trending in the right direction.

---