Interesting discussion..one person doesn't like Caldwell and the other Walsh. Both bending arguments to prop up their positions. As the least qualified to have a deep insight into football inter-workings it seems to me:

1. Before Caldwell players leaving the Jags went home. Since Caldwell most find homes on other teams and sometimes we can actually trade them.
2 The 2017 defense that was so good was anchored by players from other teams that had already been developed by others. AKA Malik Jackson, Barry Church, A.J. Bouye, Tashaun Gibson, Paul Posluszy, Calais Cambell.
3 On the other hand I do remember being extremely disappointed we chose Lernard Fornette as a running back. This was due to how he played and behaved at LSU. I felt their were many better options that year.
4. I spent my career turning around failed operations. A good 95% of the time their were a few bad employees, but the reason for the failure was supervision and management not the employees.

---