(02-03-2022, 04:14 PM)JaggedSioux Wrote:

(02-03-2022, 02:56 PM)Firesky Wrote: In the first half, with the bad picks by Trevor aside (poor decisions imho) the offense as a whole looked better. The bigger problem was the Defense allowing 4 TD's on the Pats first 4 drives and the game was out of reach before halftime. The truth doesn't mesh with you looking at a box score

Oops.




Are you out of touch with how playcalling in the NFL works? Methinks so. Let me break it down for you.

Every coach has input on the gameplan and initial script. After the first 10 or so plays the game gets handed over to the coordinator/play caller and they adapt and pick the play that works for each situation. Bevell did a poor job of that, Schotty did a better job although not completely satisfactory.

Offense under Bevell looks anemic, and can't stay on the field. Offense under Schotty ACTUALLY MOVED THE BALL AND LOOKED BALANCED, CREATIVE, AND COMPETENT!!!!  This happened with Schotty calling the plays, obviously all coaches have an input on the game plan. But when Bevell removed himself from the equation we improved. The common denominator was Bevells involvement and a direct correlation between how involved he was and the success of the offense. So we just suddenly started calling more misdirection plays and got creative magically? NO that happened after Bev gave up playcalling, use the eyetest!!!

"And Trevor said himself that he worked well with Bev, so I'll take his word over yours." .... Until he's not he's his coach, why would Trevor defame him or speak honestly if they may have to still work together? It's like when Shad asks a candidate if they'll work with Baalke as Baalke is sitting in the room. Also the results speak for themselves, nothing about our offense (sans the close of the season) "worked well" so i'll trust my eyes over Trevor's quote or your condescending opinion.

In the post before this, you said the offense, with Schotty calling plays, broke down in the Pats game because Trevor had some rookie moments. What do you think Bev encountered all season? Rookie moments, along with dropped balls, illtimed drive-killing penalties and the Urban factor.

And the misdirection plays were part of Bev's offense. He designed it, with imput from Schotty.

I know blaming the OC is the knee-jerk thing to do. Every fanbase does it. But you have to remember that this year was about taking the training wheels off of Trevor. And keeping jim upright. You might disagree, but I think this was an eye-opening year of learning for Trevor. He started a whopping 17 games and finished them all. You might opine differently, but I think Trevor is sincere when bringing up his admiration for Bev -- and Schotty. I'd speculate that there was some bad cop/good cop going in behind closed doors ... who do you think his safe harbor was, telling him to keep his chin up?

Then why did the creative playcalls and misdirection calls only surface in the finale of the season? If it's part of Bev's offense why didn't he actually call those plays (which are supposedly in his own playbook/offense) in the games he was the playcaller for?!? Yes Bevell dealt with Trevor making poor decisions (those were my exact words; not being a rookie). And speaking of being a rookie, Bill Belichick Defenses have an incredible record against rookie QB's ... lets not pretend like Bevell would've done any better because no matter who was in charge that day, could've been peak Bill Walsh and we'd have still gotten shellacked, with Bev in charge ... I'd argue we get shut out and that includes garbage time. The Colts game with Schotty having full reign of playcalling is the best our offense has performed. period, there's no argument against that objective truth.

I do believe you that Trevor may hold his offensive coaches in high regard, especially as people. But the results speak for themselves and we weren't good on Offense and it stems from a poorly built offense; Bevell did little to cater to Trevor's strengths and really foster his development; I do agree Trevor learned a lot and that's what the year was about in addition to keeping him healthy, but he could've learned so much more and so much less painfully if i'm being honest. That said, Schotty wasn't all that much better but it was definitely an improvement, look at the last week and look at all the other weeks in the season, Bevell deserves more than the fair share of blame and accountability for the failures on offense; when he removed himself from the equation we got BETTER!!!..... that's the long and short of it. I don't want either Bev or Schotty back I think both are re-treat/burnt out coaches who the game has passed by.

---