(12-27-2021, 12:14 PM)NewJagsCity Wrote:

(12-27-2021, 12:02 PM)SamusAranX Wrote: Also, the Gabbert comparisons show just how impatient and disingenuous these posters are.

Gabbert posted 15 games played in 2011, 14 started, so now is a good time compare the same sample sizes:

Gabbert 2011 Completion Percentage: 50.8
Trevor's 2021 Completion Percentage:  58.7

Gabbert 2011 YPG: 147.6
Lawrence 2021 YPG: 215.0

Gabbert 2011 YPA: 5.4
Lawrence 2021 YPA: 5.9

Gabbert 2011 Yards: 2214
Trevor 2021 Yards: 3225

Gabbert Passer Rating 2011: 65.4
Trevor Passer Rating 2021: 70.6

Gabbert QBR: 22.2
Trevor QBR:

Gabbert 1D Passing: 111
Trevor 1D Passing: 158

Gabbert Rush Yards /TD's / 1D: 98/ 0/ 8
Trevor:  Rush Yards / TD's / 1D: 301/ 2 / 18

Stop with the silliness. Trevor is not playing at a Gabbert "level". He's posting better passing and mobility numbers on a roster just as poor as 2011, except even Gabbert had a top 10 defense, a league leading TE in touchdowns, and a rushing title RB. And JDR could outcoach Bevell and Meyer any day. Gabbert also took way more sacks as he tended to curl up and go down under pressure, an observation of all during 2011. Trevor has stepped up in the pocket more times this year then Gabbert could dream of.

I agree that Lawrence is better than Gabbart, but its a little disingenious that you omitted one of the most observed stats, TD's / Int's.  Especially since they are not that different.  Why cherry pick and omit such an obvious one?  Are you that sensitive of the haters?

Gabbart - 12 td / 11 int
Lawrence - 9 td's / 14 ints

I don't think *either* of them deserved judgement on their touchdowns. When you have MJD or Robinson as a rookie, you will not be throwing it much in the redzone, especially <5 yards in or less. Neither QB could go deep their respective years; Gabbert's o-line was trash, and Lawrence doesn't get much better with help in that department. At this point, the stat is meaningless for comparison.

I will also note that three of Gabbert's touchdowns came in one game to MJD on short checkdowns.

EDIT: Also, cherry picking goes both ways. You can't ignore that Trevor is better in 95 percent of every category, and use only two stats to say he's not. However, I added the disclaimer

---