(07-16-2022, 03:11 PM)flgatorsandjags Wrote:

(07-16-2022, 02:43 PM)Cleatwood Wrote: First. I do believe the Jags defense is better which is why I said offensive weapons and not switching entire rosters.

Second. A slight edge at WR is reaching hard in the Jags favor. Wilson will likely be the best WR either team has and then the 2nd best WR for either team will be Moore. I love Kirk but I would trade Kirk for Moore or Wilson in a second. Then Davis and MJJ are a wash to me. Shenault is meh and Zay Jones is a no body for me.

Conklin and Uzomah vs Engram and Arnold? Not sure how you can give either an edge considering both are rather mediocre. Engram has never been as good ashis rookie year and Arn has never really peaked. Conklin and Uzomah are both better blockers though.

For the running backs, if you told me ETN and JRob were 100%, I would certainly give them the edge. However, both are coming off major injuries for RBs. JRob likely starts the year on PUP and they’ll be lucky if he comes back 100% at any point in his career (I know you’ll likely used Akers as an example but that’s very rare). ETN coming off Lisfranc is just as bad but I actually have more hope with him than JRob. Carter and Hall could very easily be the next really good duo in the league.

As far as the OLine, Jawaan Taylor is absolute garbage. The worst player on either team. Scherff is fantastic when healthy but that’s rare. I would take Becton and Fant over Taylor and Robinson. AVT, McGovern and Tomlinson are a better trio than Scherff, Shatley and whoever starts at LG for the Jags.

So yea. I like the Jets offensive talent (except Their QB) more than the offensive talent for the Jags.

It's funny how you only bring up Jags injuries, lmao.  Becton is their lineman and injuries is his biggest concern, Moore was injured most of last year, Davis was injured, Uzomah is coming off a serious injury!  Why didn't you bring up injuries if you want to through that into the equation? If I can take one if Wilson or Moore give me Moore, I think he will be their alpha WR if he can stay healthy.  Not to mention you say Engram only had a good rookie year, what QB has he had and what Jets TE has had a good year? ETN will be 100%, have you seen his workout videos? I'm not concerned about him and JRob is a different animal, he will be good as well.  One guy you forgot we had is Walker Little. He will be the tackle opposite Cam and our best tackle, keep bringing up Taylor lol