(03-20-2023, 03:44 AM)ChrisJagBoy Wrote:

(03-19-2023, 05:33 PM)NYC4jags Wrote: What are you on about now? 

You found posts where I talked about Herndon getting beat? Great. That was never in question or debate. Everyone and their brother knows this happened many times. 
(You said that "All you heard" from me were posts blaming Herndon or Griffin for blowing the game early on in the year - still haven't found that have you?) 

You found posts where you talked about wanting Herndon in the slot and Williams outside?  Great. That was never in question or debate. Many posters wanted that from the get go (WAY SOONER THAN THAT November post of yours), and I eventually wanted it too after seeing DW struggle enough inside combined with Herndon struggling outside. This was never in question either. 
 

Here's what was in question? 
What three games did he personally cost us? You said he lost us three games.  You still haven't answered the question? That was what STARTED ALL OF THIS. 

Name the three games.

Not gonna go thru every game of the season just to prove a point, the Broncos game is a great example and was his first start outside last year.. im sure you can find a couple more, and you absolutely were complaining about the defense because even when Trevor struggled early on all we heard from you and the others were that “well he got us a 4th qtr lead but the d blew it” and 9 times outta 10 it was shaq or tre blowing a deep ball at a critical time .


Regardless of last season, i think its pretty dumb to give guranteed money to a guy who probably should be cut during camp because i cant see a world where we dont draft at least one or two nickel backs in the draft. Same with wingard honestly but at least wingard is at an extremely thin position for us.. herndon will be below everyone on the depth chart come september

If your point is that he cost us 3 games, you don't need to go through every game to do that.  Hell, you literally only need to look at 3 total games and you've already looked at one of them.  Herndon played more than 50% of the snaps in 8 games, and roughly 33% in 2 others.  We lost 3 of those 10 games, 2 of them (DEN and NYG) where he played 2/3 of the snaps and one (KC) where he play 1/3 of the snaps.  All you need to do is show how he gave up a huge play in the NYG and KC games to prove your point.

---