Quote:Yeah I had seen that video before and I find it to be overly generous. You can find some instances of him going through progressions and reads but it is all very cherry picked.


If the staring down and not making reads were not well known issues in his game, he would be the unanimous #1 overall pick--he would basically be Andrew Luck coming out of college, but he isn't that. There are issues and big questions and that's why he is not a #1 pick and likely needs to sit for a year. My argument is that his skill set is not of the caliber of a day 1 starter and if we are serious about winning right now, we shouldn't be taking someone who isn't ready to help right now at #4.

Its just when you say all his throws are pre determined and that he can't read a defense it isn't really true. Tons of examples of him doing it over the last 3 years. Its a commonly stated notion about his that ain't true.


The staring down receivers and not seeing underneath defenders are legitimate concerns though and will be his biggest challenge going forward.

---