Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Full Version: Caldwell= Gene Smith 2.0?
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Quote:I guess, but I'm still excited for all these players. On ARob, I think we put too much stock into him having to be our #1 guy because he's not Julio Jones, etc. That said, he wasn't exactly drafted to be. Marquis was supposed to be "that guy," and ARob was meant to be a quality #2 WR. I believe that's precisely what he is. It's just we still need that legit #1 guy.
 

I always saw ARob as a possession receiver, ideally the next McCardell. But quality #2 receivers don't drop nearly half the passes thrown their way.

Quote:This would be a great thread if I had asked, "what average players did Gene bring in." I'm still looking for a single great player.
 

 

Quote:No joke. Ask Jaguars fans who are the best players on this team's roster and most would include Bortles, Colvin, Linder, Telvin Smith, ARob, Hurns and Chris Smith. These are core players now and into the future.
 

If you qualify Bortles, Colvin, and/or Chris Smith as "great" and Dwight Lowery as "average" then we'll have a very short conversation, as our definitions of "great" and "average" are clearly too far apart to even begin to imagine any sort of meaningful conversation on the topic.  :confused: 
Quote:If you qualify Bortles, Colvin, and/or Chris Smith as "great" and Dwight Lowery as "average" then we'll have a very short conversation, as our definitions of "great" and "average" are clearly too far apart to even begin to imagine any sort of meaningful conversation on the topic.  :confused:
 

You need to re-read what he wrote. He never said Bortles et al. were "great."

Quote:If you qualify Bortles, Colvin, and/or Chris Smith as "great" and Dwight Lowery as "average" then we'll have a very short conversation, as our definitions of "great" and "average" are clearly too far apart to even begin to imagine any sort of meaningful conversation on the topic. :confused:


What exactly was so great about Lowery?
Quote:What exactly was so great about Lowery?
He wasn't great but he was the best FS we've had since Deon Grant.
Quote:He wasn't great but he was the best FS we've had since Deon Grant.


The same Dwight Lowery who was constantly getting beat? Hes so good hes been in 4 different teams in 7 seasons.
Quote:What exactly was so great about Lowery?


Better safety than Jonathan Whiffrien
Quote:The same Dwight Lowery who was constantly getting beat? Hes so good hes been in 4 different teams in 7 seasons.


Not sure what you're talking about.

Not saying he was great, but he has been better than the Winston Guy and Evans fiasco.


So they let a FS go and have spent 3 off seasons trying to upgrade the position, (to no avail) .. We will see if Sergio Brown does better.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9