Quote:I'm a level minded guy, I don't just decide a qb of Brady's calibre is not a top 5 qb off a couple of games.
Likewise I won't coconsider Fitzpatrick a top qb even if he lights it up for a couple of weeks
Quote:If Fitzpatrick was putting up Luck type numbers the first 4 weeks while Brady was doing what he did the first 4 weeks, Fitzpatrick would be most definitely be playing better AT THAT TIME.
You're getting impossible to have conversation with. This isn't that hard to understand.
Read the name of op. Lastonealive is in reference to him being the Last One Alive to admit Andrew Luck is good. Is it fair that Indy gets to go from Manning to Luck? Look sometimes it happens. Montana-Young, Farve-Rodgers. Now it seems to be happening again. Manning IS the best regular season QB i have ever seen play the game, no one can dispute this. What bothers this guy is that Andrew Luck is on pace to be as good as that guy he preceded. Right now the only 2 things going for Andrew Luck is his potential and the fact that kid can straight up game with the best of them.
If Luck continues to develop at the pace he has, that's scary. Now this guys knows this. You know he does, I know he does. Heck everyone posting in this thread and has taken the time to read it knows Lastonealive is a bit irked at the pardon the pun "luck" of the Colts. 1st Manning, then Luck. If you were a fan of another AFC south team other then the Colts. You would understand the pains of this happenening all over again.
Quote:Read the name of op. Lastonealive is in reference to him being the Last One Alive to admit Andrew Luck is good. Is it fair that Indy gets to go from Manning to Luck? Look sometimes it happens. Montana-Young, Farve-Rodgers. Now it seems to be happening again. Manning IS the best regular season QB i have ever seen play the game, no one can dispute this. What bothers this guy is that Andrew Luck is on pace to be as good as that guy he preceded. Right now the only 2 things going for Andrew Luck is his potential and the fact that kid can straight up game with the best of them.
If Luck continues to develop at the pace he has, that's scary. Now this guys knows this. You know he does, I know he does. Heck everyone posting in this thread and has taken the time to read it knows Lastonealive is a bit irked at the pardon the pun "luck" of the Colts. 1st Manning, then Luck. If you were a fan of another AFC south team other then the Colts. You would understand the pains of this happenening all over again.
I said he has played well so far this season?...
Is he in Brady's class? No...
Quote:I said he has played well so far this season?...
Is he in Brady's class? No...
It's the fact that you choose to ignore that he has played exceptional since he can into the league. And what does it mean played well. If you are truly being honest, even as a jaguars fan one must admit that this year Andrew Luck is playing out of his mind. May not like him, may not like the Colts. However, if you re being real admit it. Is he in Brady's class this year. Numbers say yes. All time? No where did I read that he was as good as Brady all time. Your throwing bait and hoping for a bite is all your doing. Don't twist what someone says to make your self look more intelligent as a poster, in the end you only look more foolish.
Quote:It's the fact that you choose to ignore that he has played exceptional since he can into the league. And what does it mean played well. If you are truly being honest, even as a jaguars fan one must admit that this year Andrew Luck is playing out of his mind. May not like him, may not like the Colts. However, if you re being real admit it. Is he in Brady's class this year. Numbers say yes. All time? No where did I read that he was as good as Brady all time. Your throwing bait and hoping for a bite is all your doing. Don't twist what someone says to make your self look more intelligent as a poster, in the end you only look more foolish.
So why is he so much better this season?
He is playing at a much higher level this year than the previous 2. Watching him you can see it, and his stats are way better than he's ever put up before. He's gone from mediocre to good, still a few steps to go until he gets mentioned with the best.
Quote:So why is he so much better this season?
He is playing at a much higher level this year than the previous 2. Watching him you can see it, and his stats are way better than he's ever put up before. He's gone from mediocre to good, still a few steps to go until he gets mentioned with the best.
Could it be that it is his 3rd season and sometimes, just sometimes players actually improve from year one, to year two, to year three and so on?
Quote:Uh, what?
Chill out
Don't insult my football intelligence, chief.
Quote:Don't insult my football intelligence, chief.
Not much to insult, private.
Quote:Not much to insult, private.
This is rich, coming for you.
Quote:This is rich, coming for you.
It's a fact you have limited knowledge.
Quote:Could it be that it is his 3rd season and sometimes, just sometimes players actually improve from year one, to year two, to year three and so on?
Yeah exactly. He wasn't a top qb his first couple of seasons.
Also sometimes players don't improve,
Quote:Because it is stupid. So Coltswarriors makes top 5 QB lists every couple of weeks apparently.
He was suggesting Luck was a top 5 QB right now and Brady wasn't and I said at the time It was stupid. I got told that I was stupid and "living in the past". He should have just acknowledged at the time that Brady was still the better QB but Luck had played slightly better the previous 2 weeks...
But he didn't...He said I was "living in the past" for saying Brady was a top 5 QB
When you put quotes around something that means it was said verbatim. That didn't happen. Also, Luck was playing better than Brady the first four weeks. That's all I said LOL. Oh, and it wasn't "slightly better" than Brady. Brady was terrible the first four weeks. Quote that.
Quote:Don't insult my football intelligence, chief.
I didn't. I will insult your reading comprehension, though. I said "either we have a misunderstanding OR you lack football intelligence." See in this case the key word is OR, which if you need a definition means one or the other, to put it simply. If you're looking for an antonym, that'd be AND. Let me know if you're still confused, "chief"
Quote:When you put quotes around something that means it was said verbatim. That didn't happen. Also, Luck was playing better than Brady the first four weeks. That's all I said LOL. Oh, and it wasn't "slightly better" than Brady. Brady was terrible the first four weeks. Quote that.
I didn't. I will insult your reading comprehension, though. I said "either we have a misunderstanding OR you lack football intelligence." See in this case the key word is OR, which if you need a definition means one or the other, to put it simply. If you're looking for an antonym, that'd be AND. Let me know if you're still confused, "chief"
hail is not very bright. He is very young and immature.You're wasting your time. He will grow up someday.
Big Ben top of your ever changing top 5 CW? I take it rivers is now bottom...
Quote:Big Ben top of your ever changing top 5 CW? I take it rivers is now bottom...
You're really not very bright.
Yes, Ben is currently playing the best based on the last two weeks.
Who has played better than him the last two weeks, lastonealive?
Quote:You're really not very bright.
Yes, Ben is currently playing the best based on the last two weeks.
Who has played better than him the last two weeks, lastonealive?
So Big Ben is a top 5 qb this week?
Just confirming, because I know in future when you say Luck is a top 5 QB you just mean he had a good game
Quote:So Big Ben is a top 5 qb this week?
Just confirming, because I know in future when you say Luck is a top 5 QB you just mean he had a good game
Nope never said that and once again you avoid the question AND you make up stuff that I said.
For some reason you get off on making things up and believing that they are true.
Uhhhhh Luck good. Is it even a question anymore?
Looks like Luck is top 5 again this week!